Skip to content
Elite Picks
← Newsletter MLB Thursday, September 10, 2026

Thursday Night MLB Intel

The slate's a light one, but a Tampa Bay day game in Atlanta is doing a lot of the heavy lifting tonight, with two Rays hitters showing up near the top of the board for very different reasons. Jonny DeLuca and Jonathan Aranda both get plays out of that early Truist Park matinee, while over in Seattle, Evan Carter's cold stretch has the model looking the other way entirely. Three props, three distinct stories, and the first pitch out west doesn't even start until 4:10 ET.

Today's Top Props3 picks
Jonny DeLucaTB @ ATL · Truist Park12:15 PM ET
Over 0.5 Total Bases
94.19EP Score
65%Projected
-137Best odds
STRONG OVER ↑

DeLuca's been scuffling at the plate, hitting just .162 over his last 10 games, but total bases isn't really about batting average, it's about impact when he does connect. He's got a homer and 6 RBI in that span, which tells you the contact he is making has some pop behind it. At -137, the market's paying you to bet that he clears one total base in this Atlanta matinee, and even a single or a sac-fly-adjacent double gets it done.

Jonathan ArandaTB @ ATL · Truist Park12:15 PM ET
Over 0.5 Hits
93.03EP Score
67%Projected
-137Best odds
STRONG OVER ↑

Aranda is the more traditional form play here. He's 10-for-40 over his last 10 games, a .250 clip, with 3 homers and 8 RBI mixed in, which is a legitimately productive stretch. Just needing one hit to clear this line, with that kind of recent output, feels like a light ask. The projection sits at 1.0 hits against a 0.5 line, and Aranda's swing has clearly had some life to it lately.

Evan CarterTEX @ SEA · T-Mobile Park4:10 PM ET
Under 0.5 Hits
92.98EP Score
59%Projected
-125Best odds
STRONG UNDER ↓

Carter's the fade on this slate. He's just 6-for-30, a .200 average, over his last 10 games, and the model projects him at only 0.3 hits tonight against Texas at Seattle. That's a real step down from the two Tampa Bay bats above, and at -125 the number reflects a hitter who hasn't been finding barrels. Betting the under here is simply trusting that a cold hitter stays cold for one more night.

Key Context

Two very different reads on recent form tonight. DeLuca and Aranda are both working through mixed underlying numbers, DeLuca specifically hitting .162 but still projected over on total bases thanks to power upside, while Carter's cold spell has him going the opposite direction entirely. Worth remembering that a hits prop and a total bases prop don't always move together, even for players in similar slumps.

These are the top of the board, not all of it.Every prop is scored and ranked, with the best price for each side.
Open the MLB board Get the iOS app

Elite Picks is a research and analytics platform. We do not accept wagers. All content is for informational and research purposes.