Skip to content
Elite Picks
← Newsletter MLB Sunday, October 18, 2026

Sunday Night MLB Intel

The Rays took Game 4 behind a 7-3 win Saturday, and the ALCS is tied 2-2 heading into Game 5 at Progressive Field, with Drew Rasmussen and Parker Messick squaring off on the mound. Neither team can clinch or be eliminated tonight, but with the series knotted up, every at-bat carries a little more weight. The model is leaning on both starting pitchers to work clean, and on Tampa Bay's Chandler Simpson to stay quiet at the plate. Chandler Simpson, Parker Messick and Drew Rasmussen headline tonight's card out of the lone game on the slate.

Today's Top Props3 picks
Chandler SimpsonTB @ CLE · Progressive Field5:08 PM ET
Under 1.5 Total Bases
90.74EP Score
68%Projected
-190Best odds
STRONG UNDER ↓

Simpson has been scuffling, just 6-for-33 over his last 10 games, a .182 clip that doesn't scream extra-base pop. A total bases line of 1.5 means he needs a double or two singles to clear it, and the recent form suggests that's asking a lot right now. The model projects him right around 1.0 total bases, half a base shy of the line.

Parker MessickTB @ CLE · Progressive Field5:08 PM ET
Under 1.5 Earned Runs
90.29EP Score
56%Projected
-110Best odds
LEAN UNDER ↓

Messick gets the ball for Cleveland in Game 5, and he's been sharp lately, a 2.75 ERA with 21 strikeouts over his last five outings. That combination of missing bats and limiting damage is exactly the profile you want on a night when the model has him projected at 1.3 earned runs, just under this 1.5 line. He's CLE's announced starter tonight against a Rays lineup that just lit up the Guardians for 7 runs in Game 4, but Messick's individual form has held up well on its own merits.

Drew RasmussenTB @ CLE · Progressive Field5:08 PM ET
Under 4.5 Hits Allowed
90.00EP Score
58%Projected
-110Best odds
STRONG UNDER ↓

Rasmussen has been nearly untouchable over his last five outings, a 1.10 ERA to go with 35 strikeouts, the kind of stretch that makes a hits-allowed under feel reasonable. He's Tampa Bay's starter tonight on the road against Cleveland, and the projection sits at 4.1 hits allowed, just under the 4.5 mark. Given how few runs he's allowed lately, the model likes him to keep this one under wraps.

Key Context

All three plays tonight lean on recent individual form holding up in a series that swung hard in Game 4, when Tampa Bay's bats broke out for 7 runs. Rasmussen and Messick both carry strong recent pitching numbers into their starts, while Simpson's cold stretch at the plate is the driver on the other side of the ledger. Worth remembering: this is Game 5 of a tied series, and the individual trends point toward quieter lines for these three.

These are the top of the board, not all of it.Every prop is scored and ranked, with the best price for each side.
Open the MLB board Get the iOS app

Elite Picks is a research and analytics platform. We do not accept wagers. All content is for informational and research purposes.